Code red
Last fortnight saw a rare example
of synchronicity of three exceptionally related
events in far-flung parts of the world:
In a fortnight that was also the first anniversary
of the Mumbai train bomb blasts,
we had the storming of the Lal Masjid in Islamabad
and
the failed bomb attacks in London and Glasgow.
The common factor that binds these three events together
is the not-so-hidden hand of what has come to
be known as Islamic Terrorism on a global scale.
For Indians,
a rather shaming interest attaches to one of these
occurrences as the terrorists involved in the foiled
incidents in Britain are suspected to have Bangalore connections.
This tentative finding of the British police is a blow
to the self esteem of the citizens of this city as
the city has a well-deserved reputation
as a cosmopolitan metropolis of exceptional secularist credentials.
By far, the most traumatic of these events
By far, the most traumatic of these events
was the confrontation between the clerics
holed up in a bastion of unreconstructed Muslim orthodoxy,
the Lal Masjid in Islamabad and the
Special Service Group (SSG) —
an elite force once commanded by General Musharraf himself.
Authentic details of exactly what happened are still lacking,
what with Pakistan Government being selectively
candid about ''Operation Silence.''
According to official reports,
over a hundred people have been killed in an
operation that was reluctantly undertaken when it
could no longer be avoided and lasted 40 hours.
This extreme step was inescapable after talks with
This extreme step was inescapable after talks with
Abdul Rashid Ghazi, the negotiator on behalf
of the Lal Masjid clerics, failed.
Ghazi himself
was later killed in the crossfire.
This face off with the Lal Masjid cleric comes at
This face off with the Lal Masjid cleric comes at
the end of Musharraf's prolonged dithering over
taking effective action against this centre of
aggressive Islamic orthodoxy.
As early as 2004, its chief cleric was accused by the
government of conspiring to attack the presidential
palace and the US Embassy.
There have even been calls by Masjid sources for
the assassination of Musharraf who,
incidentally, has had other unsuccessful attempts on his life.
Despite such provocations, there was a certain reluctance
Despite such provocations, there was a certain reluctance
on the part of the government over taking head on
the cleric's increasingly shrill denunciation of the
regime and periodical violent protests.
Early in January 2007, women students of a school run
by the Masjid forcibly occupied a children's
library as a protest against government's plans to
demolish illegal mosques and madrassas.
In April, suicide attacks were threatened if the Masjid
was closed down.
Later in June, some students raided an acupuncture
clinic and took nine persons including
six Chinese women as captives,
accusing the women of prostitution.
By early July, the administration had had enough and
began its first serious encounter with the clerics,
in which nine persons died.
On July 7, Musharraf issued a stern warning that those
residing in the mosque must choose between surrender and death.
The rest is history
not yet fully told.
On the whole, the much delayed final action has had
On the whole, the much delayed final action has had
the eager approval of public opinion all over the world,
including Pakistan, where a certain ambivalence
would have been natural, especially among the
more orthodox but peace loving sections of the Muslim community.
The Pakistani media has been supportive,
on the whole, seeing a certain justification for this extreme step.
Such criticism as there has been is to the effect
that this decisive confrontation should have come much earlier.
The well-known columnist of Dawn,
Irfan Hussain, has argued on these lines.
This sanguinary encounter,
he says, may well have been avoided if only the
government had acted on his earlier
suggestion that the authorities should have cut off electricity,
water and gas supplies to the complex.
Presumably, apart from his reluctance
to take the clerics full on,
Musharraf was too busy with other problems
like his continuing confrontation with the Chief Justice.
Indian reaction to the ''Operation Silence''
Indian reaction to the ''Operation Silence''
has been muted but positive as a belated
response to a growing menace.
The media in particular has been approbative,
with some reservation about cross border
terrorism in Kashmir being inspired by
quasi-political Islamic fundamentalism.
Ironically, Pakistan itself
has now had to confront the same
fundamentalism in the activities of the fanatics
of the Lal Masjid.
The Pakistani establishment should now take
more effective steps against Islamic terrorists targeting India,
treating terrorism as a joint problem of both countries. .
On the foiled attacks in Britain and the subsequent
On the foiled attacks in Britain and the subsequent
investigations that point the finger of suspicion at
Bangalore-based individuals,
it is important that the real roots of these acts are laid
bare by the British investigating authorities.
Speaking to some women journalists,
Dr Manmohan Singh made this point in a rather ambiguous way.
He said,
''I could not sleep after watching the families
of Indians on TV last night.
Labelling Indians as terrorists or Pakistanis as terrorists
is best avoided.
Terrorists are terrorists.
They don't belong to any community or religion.''
It is likely that an unstated fear of a ''Hindu backlash''
to such characterisation was at the back of his mind
when he made these observations.
If so, it should be noted that recent instances of terrorist attack,
such as that on the suburban trains of
Mumbai last year had not led to any such retaliatory violence.
Similarly, the suspicions voiced by
British investigators about the possible
involvement of 'Bangalore-based individuals'
in the recent terrorist acts in London and Glasgow
have not led to any violence directed at the
Muslim community in the city or elsewhere.
Having said this, one cannot burke the fact that the
Having said this, one cannot burke the fact that the
three incidents listed at the beginning have Islamic inspiration.
Squeamishness in recognising this fact is misplaced.
Critical comments on these events are not
Anti-Islam but against Islamic Terrorism.
None but the most fanatical Hindu-Indian would think
that every Muslim is by definition a religious fundamentalist.
The vast majority of the
world's Muslims are peace-loving individuals.
But equally, the current wave of violence
on the global scale is inspired by Islamic fundamentalism
promoted actively by the likes of
Bin Laden and the clerics of Lal Masjid.
No comments:
Post a Comment